What to do when democracy fails.

Post Reply
coberst
Posts: 1516
Joined: Fri Dec 02, 2005 6:30 am

What to do when democracy fails.

Post by coberst »

What to do when democracy fails.

In a democracy the citizens are sovereign; when the citizens of a democracy haven’t the capacity to comprehend the problems of that democracy that democracy will fail.

Human ingenuity has proven to be capable of producing very sophisticated technology. But humans seem to be unable to develop the intellectual sophistication required to guide and control that technology. That is to say that democracy cannot function adequately in this high tech society we have created.

Our financial system’s abrupt collapse is one manifestation of this problem. Few of our experts, if any, have the sophistication to mange this high tech economy that we have created. Certainly few if any of our (USA) citizens have the sophistication to make decisions about this matter.

A large democratic state cannot consistently function within a world that is beyond the comprehension capacity of the citizens of that democracy.

We have tried Monarchy, Oligarchy, and now Democracy.

Where can we turn when our technology outstrips our intellectual sophistication?

To me the only direction that seems available is that since we cannot achieve the commensurate intellectual sophistication demanded by our technology then we must curtail the use of such sophisticated technology.
gmc
Posts: 13566
Joined: Sun Aug 29, 2004 9:44 am

What to do when democracy fails.

Post by gmc »

coberst;1091358 wrote: What to do when democracy fails.

In a democracy the citizens are sovereign; when the citizens of a democracy haven’t the capacity to comprehend the problems of that democracy that democracy will fail.

Human ingenuity has proven to be capable of producing very sophisticated technology. But humans seem to be unable to develop the intellectual sophistication required to guide and control that technology. That is to say that democracy cannot function adequately in this high tech society we have created.

Our financial system’s abrupt collapse is one manifestation of this problem. Few of our experts, if any, have the sophistication to mange this high tech economy that we have created. Certainly few if any of our (USA) citizens have the sophistication to make decisions about this matter.

A large democratic state cannot consistently function within a world that is beyond the comprehension capacity of the citizens of that democracy.

We have tried Monarchy, Oligarchy, and now Democracy.

Where can we turn when our technology outstrips our intellectual sophistication?

To me the only direction that seems available is that since we cannot achieve the commensurate intellectual sophistication demanded by our technology then we must curtail the use of such sophisticated technology.


Is that your own opinion or are you cutting and pasting someone else's?

Either way My response would be the same. Cobblers!!
coberst
Posts: 1516
Joined: Fri Dec 02, 2005 6:30 am

What to do when democracy fails.

Post by coberst »

gmc;1091362 wrote: Is that your own opinion or are you cutting and pasting someone else's?

Either way My response would be the same. Cobblers!!


How does a self-actualizing self-learner, who reads often and broadly, determine which of his or her expressions are their own creation or are constructed from those of another? I suspect ideas are fungible much like money, or water in a well.

For those who do not read books I suspect that their source of opinions is much easier to determine.
User avatar
Kindle
Posts: 7090
Joined: Mon Nov 03, 2008 5:07 pm

What to do when democracy fails.

Post by Kindle »

coberst;1091358 wrote: ...................Where can we turn when our technology outstrips our intellectual sophistication?

To me the only direction that seems available is that since we cannot achieve the commensurate intellectual sophistication demanded by our technology then we must curtail the use of such sophisticated technology.


No way will progress be stopped. We are a consumer society and if there is a buck to be made, someone will upgrade their circumstances by marketing it.




"Out, damned spot! out, I say!"

- William Shakespeare, Macbeth, 5.1
Post Reply

Return to “Philosophy”