ForumGarden

tmbsgrl wrote: Hey everyone.. I wasn't shocked to see Melissa go.. I was hoping Kevin would go.. I don't like him.. Maybe next week! I was surprised to see Ace and Lisa in the top 3! My guesses were Kellie, Kevin & Elliot. I can't wait for next week!:)


I would've thought Kevin, Melissa, & probably Kellie.

Ok hurry up and finish watching American Idol, so we can discuss it.

I felt like I was being stared down by BabyRider's emu from one person. Ya'll have to guess who it was. :wah:

I'd have to probably say Chris??

So, who do y'all think will go this week? I think it'll probably be Lisa. I hate to say it, but that's my pick.

Nah it was Kevin, I felt was staring at me.



Anyways I thought Kellie really did an awesome job last night with the Patsy Cline song. Chris was pretty great too with his version of i walk the line.



Did anyone else notice all the technical problems last night?

Sheryl wrote: Nah it was Kevin, I felt was staring at me.



Anyways I thought Kellie really did an awesome job last night with the Patsy Cline song. Chris was pretty great too with his version of i walk the line.



Did anyone else notice all the technical problems last night?


Yes, I noticed them! I thought it was because Kellie jumped up & down.

I thought Mandisa was AWSOME! She was impossible to follow, IMO. I voted for her, Taylor, Chris & Kellie. I thought Chris's version, while way out there was really cool. Kellie did a great job with the Patsy Cline song, but did anyone else notice how she was saying certain words?? Almost sounded like she was trying to be FRENCH!!

I'm hoping that country boy will go. He's past his expiration date I think.

tmbsgrl wrote: Bucky??? You want Bucky to go? NO!:yh_shame I want Kevin to leave!:yh_prayI suppose they can't do like Mr Trump and fire both at once. :yh_think

He's just at or near the bottom of a high quality pile.

Accountable wrote: He's just at or near the bottom of a high quality pile.


I have to agree, Acc. He WAS in the bottom 3. I was pretty sure Lisa would go. But I must say, I'm glad she didn't. I felt sorry for Kevin, but it was his time. I honestly hope Bucky's next... sorry!

last night was a complete preview of the next two week's shows. Every one of those last three is eclipsed so much by the others, it's almost certain that they will all get voted off one after another. The really interesting shows will be the final seven.

I was sad to see Kevin go, I wish it had been Bucky. But I agree with Jives, it will be the last 7 shows that are the most interesting.

Sheryl wrote: I was sad to see Kevin go, I wish it had been Bucky. But I agree with Jives, it will be the last 7 shows that are the most interesting.


I think I have to agree with Jives too.

Question: Does anyone else think there may be something going on between Chris & Kellie?? They're always hugging & talking & sitting next to each other. I really hope I'm wrong... cuz Chris is kinda MARRIED! :-2

tmbsgrl wrote: Yeah I brought that up earlier in this thread. I think there IS.


I thought somebody had! That is totally wrong! And as much as I like her, I can't stand the dumb blonde act. It's getting reeeeeeaaaaallll old!!!

So, who do you think will go this week?

tmbsgrl wrote: Honestly I think Kelly will go. She did horrible. I really liked Bucky last night. I voted for him.


Kellie didn't do that great, but then neither did Lisa. I think it'll be Lisa. And I really wasn't impressed with Ace. I thought Mandisa was good again, & didn't deserve the criticism that they gave her. She sang a Christian Rock song, so what?? She was still good! I still like Taylor! I voted for Mandisa & Taylor.

They all did poorly, except possibly Paris. I couldn't understand a word Bucky sang. The first girl will go this time.

Alot of them did poorly last night. Kelly and Ace did horribly. I voted for Bucky and Elliot.

Accountable wrote: They all did poorly, except possibly Paris. I couldn't understand a word Bucky sang. The first girl will go this time.


Unfortunately, I was on the phone with my daughter when Paris was singing. But the judges were pretty harsh last night, IMO! I don't think any of them, including Katharine, did their greatest. But I could understand Bucky. Maybe it's because I know the song?

I fell asleep before Idol came on last night!!! Who got booted????

observer1 wrote: I fell asleep before Idol came on last night!!! Who got booted????
I dunno what her name was....the 16 yr old girl with the long curly hair.

Lil~Basco wrote: I dunno what her name was....the 16 yr old girl with the long curly hair.


Lisa.

Ok what was the dance Shakira was doing last night when she performed. I thought it was a form of belly dancing, but Im not sure. I just wanna learn to move like that. :wah:

I bet Bucky's next...

Ok, what did you guys think of Idol last night? Who goes?

observer1 wrote: Ok, what did you guys think of Idol last night? Who goes?


I think Katharine did poorly I thought Mandisa did fantastic, wow she sure can belt out a tune.

tmbsgrl wrote: I'm not sure. I really liked Bucky lastnight. He did great. My husband thinks he was the best. I didn't like Mandisa at all. Taylor picked the wrong song. Ace & Chris were my favorites. Kellie sounded great-i thought. Katherine was good too. So was Paris. Elliot sucked I thought & they all gave him good 'reviews'. So I guess it is between Elliot and Mandisa. Maybe Kellie too.


Well, I wasn't crazy about Taylor's choice of song, but he had the disadvantage of being first, too. I thought Mandisa's version of that song stank & I really like Mandisa. I wasn't impressed with Elliott. Paris was alright. Kellie was good! Katharine was so-so. I really liked Ace & Chris last night!! And Bucky surprised me!

I'd have to say either Mandisa or Elliott, unfortunately.

Wow we all thought different on everyone huh!

I thought Bucky rocked last night. That and I loved the song he sang last night. I thought Elliot did pretty good last night, way better than Mandissa. When she first started singing, I thought she was bout to rap a Shania Twain song. :-3

I thought Kelly did great, but I hated how they rearranged the song.

Well, unfortunately, we all seem to be in agreement about Mandisa. Sad, cuz I really do like her! Yes, I thought Bucky did very well last night. And so did Kellie!

Ohh man I wanna chat bout who got voted off. Mouths shut till everyone's seen it............

IM SO PI$$ED! Mandiva went over Bucky and Paris and for God's sake KElly the dumba$$? Are you kidding me? THat girl has some pipes and a great attitude!! Im never watching that show again. USA is full of a bunch of freakin idiots!!! Just goes to show you they have no artistic taste whatsoever!!!

As long as she has big boobs and a skinny waste, who cares what she sings like, right? And as long as the guy has some hot hair, he could be flat as a pancake!

DAMMIT!

I only liked Mandisa and Chris. That was it. I think the others are mainstream and mediocre and sound just like everyone else out there (except maybe Taylor). THere is nothing "unique" about any of the rest of them.

tmbsgrl wrote: Kellie- I love her voice & I could listen to her sing or talk for hours.


Arent you kind of tired of her playing up the dumb blonde Jessica bit? It was funny and cute the first couple of times, but now she just grates on my nerves, no one can be THAT stupid and naive, IMO.

I'll give you Elliot. He is good. But I cant stand all the "trailing" these people are putting in lately.

Im sure my girl MANDISA will have a CD out soon and I will buy it, that way I can listen to her all the time.

I don't think Kellie is dumb, just naive. She went from small town, to the big city. I was shocked that Mandissa got voted off, but was glad to see Elliot stay. I like him, he's a down to earth guy.

Next week's theme is Queen, I'm excited to see who performs what.

I was upset to see Mandisa go, but I didn't think she performed very well this week. And that's what we're voting on, unfortunately.... how they did THIS week. I REALLY liked her & would DEFINITELY buy her CD.

I don't think Chris is all that great. I thought he was good this week, though. I don't think he'll make it to the top. It'll be close. I'm kinda getting tired of Elliott. Bucky's alright. But I don't think he'll do good with Queen.

I wasn't impressed with Katharine this week either. But I did like Kellie's performance. Yeah, I'm getting tired of the ditzy blonde thing, along with a LOT of people. But she still did good. We're not voting on a popularity contest. This is based on their vocal ability THIS week.

Didja notice... the tension seemed kinda in the air when they put Chris in Kellie's group. Then they only shook hands when they were able to sit down & Chris hugged Taylor. Methinks something may have been said to Chris by Wifey... :-2

I was wondering why Ryan announced that Ace was "officially" single the other night. Wasn't he before? :-3

I missed both shows. But I hear I didn't miss much, performance-wise.

Who is your pick to go this week? I honestly think it'll be Elliott. I really think Bucky did a good job last night, as well as Kellie! And I liked Taylor too. Katharine's song was very good too. I wasn't extremely impressed with Ace and I didn't know Chris's song & didn't care too much for it. But his vocals were very good. I really liked Paris too.