ForumGarden

That Ace has the cutest smile! But I'm sure he knows it too. I think Chris is cute!

Sorry guys I wanted Sway gone over Kevin. Kevin is just cute, I like him.

I was sooo glad to see Briana gone.

tmbsgrl wrote: Hey Sheryl. Yeah I like Kevin too But I liked Sway better. It make me laugh when Ryan said that he had found Kevin Body double for a movie.. It was Chicken Little lol.. :wah: He really did look like him!


Didn't he though???

I thought Sway sang that Earth Wind & Fire song excellently last week. He has a great voice!

Ok I'll admit I'm one of those who can't but to cheer on the underdog. And my husband said that he looked just like a kid he went to college with that was called birdass.



And yea I was laughing when they showed his body double, espicially since what my husband had said who he looked like. :wah:

Hey, TG, Chris is married. At least, he has a wedding band on. I HOPE they're not having something going on.

I LOVED Mandisa the other night!! She totally ROCKED!!! It's not fair not to vote for her, just cuz hubby doesn't like her, IMO. Is it something personal?

I voted for Taylor & Gedeon & Kevin last night. Even though, I think Will will go tonight & either Gedeon or Kevin.

I think that Kinnik & Melissa might go tonight too.

What do you think?

You must've missed the video where Chris talked about his kids.



I think you're right on all counts. It's sad that Taylor won't win, but I hope he stays until the end. I love that voice!



And Ace blew the roof off last night. Very impressive! They're probably debating right now whether to let is slip that he's gay. It'll gain some guy votes but lose some girl votes. :yh_think hmmmm What to do? What to do?

Accountable wrote: You must've missed the video where Chris talked about his kids.



I think you're right on all counts. It's sad that Taylor won't win, but I hope he stays until the end. I love that voice!



And Ace blew the roof off last night. Very impressive! They're probably debating right now whether to let is slip that he's gay. It'll gain some guy votes but lose some girl votes. :yh_think hmmmm What to do? What to do?


Honestly, I was more impressed with Taylor than Ace. Ace, IMO, was just OK, as Simon said.

So, after I watched the males perform last night, I would have to say that Taylor was the best, Bucky was really good too, and Chris. They are my top three for the guys! I love watching Taylor perform, he just puts a smile on my face and makes me feel good. He is my pick for idol!:guitarist

Mine, too. I just hope all the young'uns that vote like him. :rolleyes:

tmbsgrl wrote: Chris is married and he has 2 kids. SO I hope not either. I don't really like Mandisa she doesn't fit the star look...
Video killed the Radio Star. :guitarist

Ace is my pick to win for the guys, he just seems to know how to work the crowd. he has the look, the personality, and the voice.

That's the best part about this season. The men are soooo different in voice and style.

I literally broke down into tears when Kevin sang Vincent! And I got goosebumps when Mandisa sang the other night. There are a lot of people who do have the look. If that was the case years ago, we probably wouldn't have Aretha Franklin or Ray Charles. She's extremely talented, that's what counts.

Okay I missed it. Who got cut?

Accountable wrote: Okay I missed it. Who got cut?


Kinnik & Ayla (I was very surprised about Ayla)

Will & Gedeon (I figured these two, but was sad to see them go)

Ayla was that tall athlete, right? She was definitely not the worst. Her voice was pretty powerful.

Accountable wrote: Ayla was that tall athlete, right? She was definitely not the worst. Her voice was pretty powerful.


Yep, that's her. I was surprised. I thought Melissa was going. Ayla cried. Felt bad for her. I don't think she's used to losing.

She probably wanted to hit somebody, but knew it wouldn't be right.

Accountable wrote: She probably wanted to hit somebody, but knew it wouldn't be right.


You're sooo bad!!!!

I was sad to see her go too. The guys who went were the ones I wanted to go.

Sheryl wrote: I was sad to see her go too. The guys who went were the ones I wanted to go.


I didn't want them to go, but figured they would. I liked Gedeon! I love that old Motown sound!

observer1 wrote: I didn't want them to go, but figured they would. I liked Gedeon! I love that old Motown sound!
Me too, but he just wasn't Idol quality, was he?

Gideon's smile bothered me, and he was a little cocky.

Accountable wrote: Me too, but he just wasn't Idol quality, was he?


To me, he just wasn't powerful enough... like I thought Mandisa was. I thought, for the guys, Taylor was the most "powerful" the other night.

Sheryl wrote: Gideon's smile bothered me, and he was a little cocky.


I liked Gedeon's smile. He reminded me of Buckwheat from the Little Rascals!! LOL!!

I would think Ace or Chris are cockier.

I think Chris and Ace are gonna go far on their looks, but I still like Elliot and Taylor better.

Not sure what it was bout Gidion that made me think he was so cocky, guess it was just me.

Well, once again, I thought Mandisa was dynamic!! And I also thought Taylor did a great job! I liked his hair last night, too! It had a little more style to it.

Unfortunately, I think it's time for Kevin to go. He just doesn't have it going on. I wasn't real impressed with Melissa either.

I really like Kellie (she's been one of my faves), but that whole dumb southern girl routine is kinda wearing thin now. Makes me wonder how much she's playing the people, ya know??

What do you guys think?

I agree on all counts. I was disappointed with the other 16-year-old girl (I forget her name but not Paris). She's far better than that performance.



Katherine is very polished. Do you think she may be too polished?

Accountable wrote: I agree on all counts. I was disappointed with the other 16-year-old girl (I forget her name but not Paris). She's far better than that performance.



Katherine is very polished. Do you think she may be too polished?


I'm starting to like Katherine more as the weeks wear on. But she DID have voice lessons from her mom all her life. Quite an advantage. She's roommates with Kellie, did you know that?

You were saying about Lisa Turner. I agree. That wasn't her best performance. But then, I'm just not a huge Stevie Wonder fan... please don't hate me!

observer1 wrote: I'm starting to like Katherine more as the weeks wear on. But she DID have voice lessons from her mom all her life. Quite an advantage. She's roommates with Kellie, did you know that?



You were saying about Lisa Turner. I agree. That wasn't her best performance. But then, I'm just not a huge Stevie Wonder fan... please don't hate me!


:eek: ........... I don't think I know you anymore. :yh_silent

Accountable wrote: ........... I don't think I know you anymore. :yh_silent


Please forgive me!! :yh_pray :yh_brokeh

observer1 wrote: Please forgive me!! :yh_pray :yh_brokeh
DONE! :-6

So who do ya'll think will go home tonight? I'm thinking it's probaly going to be Bucky. Also is anyone else just not getting wowed by Ace. Yea he's good looking, but I think Kevin sings better than him.

I think Kevin's wise beyond his years. Wise enough to know he's riding a wave, meaning he's not really in control here. He's there because he's cute and he knows it.

I have to agree about Kevin. Time to go, Dude! You're NOT sexy! I like Kellie, but I'm starting to think she's acting ditzy just to stay in. Ace is cute, but...

I like Mandisa, Taylor, Chris & Katherine. Although I really wasn't crazy about Chris's version of his song last night. I know he did the Chili Peppers' version. But still...

Well, gotta go! See y'all!

OK, I missed Idol last night. What did I miss??????

observer1 wrote: OK, I missed Idol last night. What did I miss??????
1/2 hour show. Stevie sang something new (I missed most of it) and Melissa got the boot.



Ace & Lisa were also in the bottom 3.

Boy, was I shocked at who the bottom three were. I really thought that Kevin, Kellie and lisa would be the bottom three. Although I was relieved to see the three that I voted for, safe.

I really liked Melissa's voice and was disappointed to see her go...

WOW!! I'm with you Acc. Is it on tonight?

observer1 wrote: WOW!! I'm with you Acc. Is it on tonight?
No, we're in the final 12. Only 2 shows per week now.