Kilts, tartans and clans

A forum to discuss local issues in Scotland.
User avatar
Chookie
Posts: 1826
Joined: Sun Oct 29, 2006 11:55 am

Kilts, tartans and clans

Post by Chookie »

A great deal of time has been spent by a great many historians, commentators and authors on discussing the clan system in highland Scotland. A great deal more will, no doubt, be wasted in the future. What follows is nothing more than a (possibly somewhat jaundiced) view from the inside.



Imagine, if you will, you are living in eighteenth century Europe and you become aware that there is a tribal society in full flower – in civilised Europe??? Shock, horror (et cetera, et cetera, ad bloody nauseum).....Is this not unthinkable?

Well, no, it isn't, not really. To be aware of the existence of this society, you have to have the time and resources, not to mention money, and the inquiring mind (also known as nosey-bastardness) to hunt for this fact.

Clans 101:-

The clan (Gaelic: clann, meaning children) was, at the most basic level, a feudal arrangement in which the inhabitants of a district are given protection by a military “elite” in return for a (largeish) chunk of the inhabitants crops (this being the Norman-French model – which became the European norm). In the highlands of Scotland, and in Ireland to a lesser extent, feudalism developed differently.

A clan became a self-sufficient and self-supporting association of people living in a specific district. Over time they intermarried, married-in and married-out until the majority of those a district considered themselves to be all of one family, from the poorest peasant or landless man, right up to the chief. Or, at least, such is the theory. However it's highly unlikely that everybody a specific district (any district) was related.

Even so, this is not in any way descriptive of a clan. It's merely an attempt to put it in perspective. Possibly the biggest contrast to the Norman-French system is the fact that in the clan system the local capo d' capo tutti, became the focal point of the clan. Unlike feudalism in the rest of Europe, where the local big-wigs were, to an extent, interchangeable, in the Gaelic speaking areas of Scotland and Ireland they weren't, they were, basically primus inter pares. There was also the office of the taniste. This office can be described as a sort of apprentice chief.

Walter Scott:

Tartan is great. Or is it? Tartans as they are known to today are an invention of Sir Walter Scott – to celebrate the extremely unusual visit of King George IV (previously known as “Prinnie”, that same Prince George who claimed to have fought at Waterloo – he didn't) to Scotland in 1822 (the first time a “Royal” had been in Scotland since Charlie II pissed off Londonwards in sixteen hundred and whateveritwas).

Walter Scott, and to a much greater extent, James MacPherson were largely responsible for the fascination with clans, kilts and tartans which still colour how the world sees Scotland (quaint, other-worldly and picturesque). Picturesque I will agree with...

The Victorians took this fascination to an absurd length, inventing many new “ancient” tartans and inventive ways to wear them - can you say Brigadoon? Incidentally all that bullshit about Brigadoon is based on an old story about the mythical German village of Germelshausen that fell under an evil magic curse.

Kilts:

OK, being entitled to wear a kilt rocks.

Really? Anybody can wear a bloody kilt. The wearing of either the Great kilt or the modern version the feile-beag or “little kilt” devised by Thomas Rawlinson, an ironmaster in Glenmoriston (and shock! horror! The ultimate insult!!! an Englishman!) isn't somehow magically reserved purely for those of purely Scottish blood. You'll be noticing that I didn't say invented although many people – Scots and non-Scots - claim the kilt was invented by an Englishman, they will not or cannot name him.

Why did I say devised? Basically because the Egyptians wore a form of kilt (defining a kilt as an un-bifurcated garment which covers the wearer between waist and knee – which basically says it's a skirt). There is also a Pictish carving showing a man wearing just such a garment (he's also getting tore into a drinking horn, so no change there....)

The Great Kilt (feile-mor) is different. It's a chunk of cloth measuring 54 inches or so in height and 7 or 8 yards in length. Being of closely woven wool it's a bit on the heavy side. The origins of the great kilt are lost in the mists of antiquity. At a stretch – admittedly, a long one – it may be related to the toga. If so, the method of wearing it was very different. To don the great kilt it is necessary to lay a belt out on the floor, take the kilt and lay out a series of pleats, lie down, haul the sides in and cross them over, fasten the belt then (if you can) stand up. This leaves you with big chunk of cloth to be distributed above the waist.........
An ye harm none, do what ye will....
luciferjohn
Posts: 245
Joined: Thu Sep 03, 2009 1:18 pm

Kilts, tartans and clans

Post by luciferjohn »

the kilt,was a common mode of dress for the northern tribes, in the bc era,everyone from scotts,to germanics , even russians wore them, i guess it was easier then inventing pants?:Dseriously it was common in the bc era,the longer version, it is my assumtion that the great kilt is just a logical spring and fall adaption,oh for others, i was kidding about the pants thing we germanics wore them in the winter, i believe all northern tribes did.:D
:driving:lookout smart guy talkin:guitarist:yh_devil:yh_ghost:
User avatar
Nomad
Posts: 25864
Joined: Thu Jun 30, 2005 9:36 am

Kilts, tartans and clans

Post by Nomad »

luciferjohn;1237895 wrote: the kilt,was a common mode of dress for the northern tribes, in the bc era,everyone from scotts,to germanics , even russians wore them




Were they cross dressing homosexuals?
I AM AWESOME MAN
User avatar
Oscar Namechange
Posts: 31842
Joined: Wed Jul 30, 2008 9:26 am

Kilts, tartans and clans

Post by Oscar Namechange »

Nomad;1237957 wrote: Were they cross dressing homosexuals? Yes.
At the going down of the sun and in the morning, we will remember them. R.L. Binyon
User avatar
Odie
Posts: 33482
Joined: Mon Jul 21, 2008 9:10 pm

Kilts, tartans and clans

Post by Odie »

Nomad;1237957 wrote: Were they cross dressing homosexuals?


watch it eh, I have my own Scottish tartan.:sneaky:
Life is just to short for drama.
User avatar
Oscar Namechange
Posts: 31842
Joined: Wed Jul 30, 2008 9:26 am

Kilts, tartans and clans

Post by Oscar Namechange »

Odie;1237986 wrote: watch it eh, I have my own Scottish tartan.:sneaky:
:wah:
At the going down of the sun and in the morning, we will remember them. R.L. Binyon
User avatar
Odie
Posts: 33482
Joined: Mon Jul 21, 2008 9:10 pm

Kilts, tartans and clans

Post by Odie »

oscar;1237995 wrote: :wah:


stop laughing, I do have my own, so there!:yh_rotfl:yh_rotfl
Life is just to short for drama.
User avatar
Oscar Namechange
Posts: 31842
Joined: Wed Jul 30, 2008 9:26 am

Kilts, tartans and clans

Post by Oscar Namechange »

Odie;1238002 wrote: stop laughing, I do have my own, so there!:yh_rotfl:yh_rotfl
Well, my family has a coat of arms.... does that count?:sneaky:
At the going down of the sun and in the morning, we will remember them. R.L. Binyon
User avatar
Odie
Posts: 33482
Joined: Mon Jul 21, 2008 9:10 pm

Kilts, tartans and clans

Post by Odie »

oscar;1238010 wrote: Well, my family has a coat of arms.... does that count?:sneaky:


yes.........mine does to.:p:p
Life is just to short for drama.
luciferjohn
Posts: 245
Joined: Thu Sep 03, 2009 1:18 pm

Kilts, tartans and clans

Post by luciferjohn »

oscar;1238010 wrote: Well, my family has a coat of arms.... does that count?:sneaky:


so does mine but i dont have a kilt, cant find one in a 56 inch waist:-5
:driving:lookout smart guy talkin:guitarist:yh_devil:yh_ghost:
User avatar
Odie
Posts: 33482
Joined: Mon Jul 21, 2008 9:10 pm

Kilts, tartans and clans

Post by Odie »

luciferjohn;1238041 wrote: so does mine but i dont have a kilt, cant find one in a 56 inch waist:-5


buy the material and have one made.
Life is just to short for drama.

Return to “Scotland”